Hi! Welcome to satish24k - It's Not Just Central Government Employeees News, but We Strive To Present You Whatever You Might Be Interested In.......................Chief Editor - kavitaSatish, Just a COMMON MAN with UNCOMMON DREAMS.......... LIFE IS NOT WHAT WE GET FROM BIRTH, IT IS WHAT WE MAKE OUT OF EVERY MOMENT WE LIVE; SO MAKE BEST OUT OF IT.......HAVE A GREAT LIFE

Monday, December 27, 2010

Employees may not be able to challenge CAT judgement in SC



NEW DELHI: Bad news is in store for government employees contesting matters relating to their service conditions in the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) as they may not be able to challenge the judgement in the Supreme Court.

Government employees not satisfied with CAT orders on their service matters will continue to appeal in High Courts as government's plan to enable them approach the apex court directly has received a thumbs down from the top law officer.

Recently, the Department of Personnel had asked the Law Ministry whether the present system of CAT orders being challenged in High Courts be changed to fast track disposal of cases of government employees relating to their service conditions and employment rules.

The Law Ministry referred the matter to Attorney General Ghoolam Vahanvati who opined against the move saying a 1997 Supreme Court judgement on the issue should continued to be followed.

"As of now, the buck stops here (on the issue)," Law Minister M Veerappa Moily told PTI when asked to comment on Vahanvati's opinion.
He said his ministry was trying to find a solution. "But I would not like to add anything more to it," he added.

When the CAT was established in 1985 by an Act of Parliament, its rules clearly stated that its judgements on service related matters of state and central government employees can only be challenged in the apex court.

While the same rules is in operation even today, a 1997 Supreme Court ruling held that judicial review is the basic feature of the Constitution and a High Court's power on judicial review cannot be taken away.

After the judgement, appeals against CAT rulings were entertained in High Courts.

"The Armed Forces Tribunal Act has been borrowed from CAT. Appeals against Tribunal's orders can only be challenged in the Supreme Court. But in CAT's case, it has become a three tier system...the entire purpose of CAT has been defeated," said a CAT functionary.

He said while CAT usually disposes off a case in six months, appeal in High Court often takes years.

"They pay Rs 50 as fee to move CAT, but they have to pay thousands of rupees in High Court...if the matter reaches Supreme Court, the time and cost involved is massive," he said.




Print Friendly and PDFPrintPrint Friendly and PDFPDF


For Further Reading,
EMPLOYEES NEWS

0 comments:

By Blog Gadgets

Choose Your Subject

2013 WALLPAPERS 7th Pay Commission AADHAR ACCOUNTS AIPEU AIR INDIA AIRF AIRTRAVEL ALLOWANCES AMAGING AMAZING ANNA HAZARE ANOMALY ANTI CORRUPTION MOVEMENT AUTISM BABIES BANKING BIRDS WALLPAPERS BLOGGING BONUS BSNL BUDGET Cadre Restructure Calenders CANCER CASUAL LABOURS CAT CAT Orders CBSE CCL CCS CCS PENSION CCS(JT) Rules 1979 CGHS CHARTS CHILD CARE Child Care Allowance CHILDREN EDUCATION ALLOWANCE CHINA CIRCULARS Compassionate Appointment CONSUMER NEWS Conveyance Allowance Court Orders CPWD CREATIVITY CRICKET. SPORTS WALLPAPERS CSD CSS CVC Cycle Maintenance Allowance DA DA MERGER DEFENCE DEFENSE DIGITAL INDIA DIGITAL LIFE CERTIFICATE DISABLED DOPT DOWNLOAD DPE DRDO eCards ECHS EDUCATION eMO EMPLOYEES NEWS EMPLOYMENT NEWS ENTERTAINMENT EPFO ESTATES EX SERVICEMEN EXAMINATIONS FACEBOOK FAQs FDI FESTIVALS FIGHT FOR JUSTICE FINANCE BILL 2013 FINMIN FLOWERS FORMs FUNNY PICTURES g GADGETS Ganesha Wallpapers GDS GENERAL KNOWLEDGE GENERAL KNOWLEDGE - CURRENT AFFAIRS GOD WALLPAPERS GPF GREETINGS Group B HBA HEALTH HIGH DEFINITION WALLPAPER HOLIDAYS Hostel Subsidy Allowance HRA IAS IBA IDA INCOME TAX INCREMENT INDEPENDENCE DAY INDEX NUMBERS INDIA INSURANCE INVESTMENT IP/ASP IPO Exam ISLAM JOINING TIME KIDS KVS LATEST POSTAL NEWS Latest Releases from PIB LEAVE LOKAYUKTA LOVE LTC MACPS MAKE IN INDIA MEDICAL Meghdoot Millennium MHA MOBILE BANKING MOBILE WALLPAPERS MOF MOTHER MY CORNER NATURE WALLPAPERS NEGATIVE LIST NEWS NPS One Rank One Pension ORDERS ORDINANCE PARLIAMENT NEWS PENSION People you must know PERSMIN PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT PERSONOLITY DEVELOPMENT PFRDA POLITICS POSTAL TECHNOLOGY Postings PPF Promotions QUESTION PAPERS QUOTES RAILWAY NEWS RAJYASABHA NEWS RBI RECRUITMENT REIMBURSEMENT RELIGION REPUBLIC DAY RESERVATION RESULTS Retirement Age RTI SANATANA DHARMA Sanchaya Post SAPOST SBCO SC SCIENCE SCOVA SECULAR SEXUAL HARASSMENT SKIN CARE SLEEP SMS SMS-GOODNIGHT SPEEDNET ST Study Material TATKAL TEACHERS TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY TIPS TERRORISM TRANSFER TRAVEL Travelling Allowance Troubleshooting Problems in Postal Applications UNION NEWS UPSC VIDEOS Virus Wallpapers Washing Allowance WILD PHOTOGRAPHY WOMAN ಕನ್ನಡಿಗ

Popular Posts of the Month

All Time Popular Posts

 
Blogger Wordpress Gadgets